A shepherd in the biblical sense of that word, David Thomann cared for the sheep that had been entrusted by God to his care, whether they were in Catasauqua, PA, where he began his pastoral ministry in the Bible Fellowship Church, or at Faith BFC, Lancaster, PA, where he served for 39 years as Faith’s senior pastor.
Pastor Thomann, who left this life for glory on March 26, 2025 after a lengthy illness, was the kind of pastor who leaves an impression on people. Outgoing, with many interests ranging from golf to singing and playing the guitar and trumpet, to cheering for his beloved Philadelphia 76ers and San Francisco Giants, Thomann was the kind of person who made you feel like you mattered, and that he enjoyed spending time with you. But at the same time, his overarching love was for the God and Father of his Lord, Jesus Christ, and for conveying gospel truth to his people in a variety of settings.
When Faith BFC held a celebration of life service for its longtime shepherd on April 12, though Thomann had retired in 2019, hundreds came out to honor his legacy and pay their respects to his family.
“I know for me, I would not be who I am or where I am today, apart from how the Lord worked in and through Pastor Thomann to invest in me, influence me, and give shape to my life and my ministry,” stressed Keith A. Long, Thomann’s successor as Faith’s senior pastor. “For that I am forever thankful to him and to the Lord.”
Born in Jersey City, NJ, to Rev. David E. and Pauline Thomann, Thomann graduated from Souderton High School (PA) and then earned degrees from Pinebrook Junior College and United Wesleyan. Feeling called by God to pastoral ministry, he attended Conservative Baptist Seminary in Denver, CO, before returning to his alma mater as athletic director and director of admissions at Pinebrook Junior College.
After a short stint as youth pastor at Twin Lakes Baptist Church, Santa Cruz, CA, Thomann came home to the Bible Fellowship Church, first as pastor at Catasauqua BFC for two years and then moving to Lancaster, where he enjoyed a long and fruitful ministry as senior pastor there.
Thomann was a dyed-in-the wool BFC loyalist; the list of his BFC commitments was a long one that included service on numerous boards and committees, and at least six study committees. Also he served 16 years as Annual Conference Secretary, and 25 years on the Statistics Committee. “God’s amazing grace was the banner over Pastor Dave’s life and ministry,” noted longtime friend and fellow BFC pastor, William G. Schlonecker. “Dave loved the Bible Fellowship Church and made an impact, not only in the local pastorate but denominationally as well.”
At Faith, Thomann oversaw multiple times of growth and expansion, including the church’s move to its current location on Donerville Road in Lancaster. He correctly understood that while providing leadership is essential to the role of pastor, the primary role of a minister is that of shepherd – loving, feeding, and caring for people.”
“Dad loved people,” Thomann’s daughter Tara Wise said. “He also loved his family, but we knew that sacrifice was needed for his calling to the ministry, and we were proud of the legacy that he upheld.” The Apostle Peter’s instructions in 1 Peter 5:2-4 closely aligned with how Dave Thomann saw his life as a pastor: “…shepherd the flock of God that is among you, exercising oversight, not under compulsion, but willingly, as God would have you; not for shameful gain, but eagerly, not domineering over those in your charge, but being examples to the flock. And when the chief Shepherd appears, you will receive the unfading crown of glory.”
Thomann’s gifting included a strong pulpit ministry that leaned heavily on evangelism and on accurately teaching Scripture. He was committed to declaring “the full counsel of God.” “A good shepherd is not known by how gently he pets the sheep,” John MacArthur says. “A good shepherd is known by how well he protects them and feeds them.”
David leaves behind Patricia, his wife of 52 years, as well as children Tricia (husband Randy) Warfel, David (Elva) Thomann, Tara (Doug) Wise and adopted children-grandchildren Donavan and Haley Thomann. His legacy also includes grandchildren R. J., John, Henry, Ashtyn, Ashley, Elsie, Brooks, Sophia, and Isabella. His sisters include Betty (Arthur) Frable and Beverly Thomann.
Ultimately, his legacy also includes numerous men who later became pastors, among them a nephew, Brian Frable, who preached at Thomann’s memorial service and serves as pastor of Kona Baptist Church in Hawaii. “Dave Thomann helped me realize what God had for me, and that my life had a purpose … to glorify God in all that I do,” Frable said.
